How to Save Newspapers Part II

In August of 2013 I wrote a blog on how to save newspapers (http://gwrresearch.blogspot.com/2013/08/how-to-save-newspapers.html) . This blog described the differences between print and digital editions of a newspaper and their websites. The article focused on creating a symbiotic relationship between the newspaper and the website.

I see that newspapers are trying to create a business model that relies on inputs from electronic and print components but I don’t see much symbiosis.  Most of newspaper efforts still seem to be driven by the old model and its strengths. 

News stories are printed in the paper and digital editions with reference to those stories being repeated in a different format and different timing on the website.  I saw, in one newspaper, a large photo (half page) of an event with a caption telling the readers they could learn more about the event on the newspaper’s website.

Now there is a synergistic effort gone bad. The folks getting the newspaper don’t get the story and those on the website are reading what should have been in the newspaper. Newspapers strength is built on great journalism  and great photojournalism. These are its strengths. The Internet strength is built on immediacy and audio-video capabilities. The strengths of both platforms were wasted with this effort.

When I was in the newspaper business there was this desire to also own television stations so its audio-visual capabilities could enhance coverage and create new revenue streams.   Why is it then, that newspapers now have access to a medium to exploit audio-visual capabilities and fail to use them? In the example above why not have a great photo (smaller) and a good story with a reference to a video of the event on the website? This is synergy – using the strength of both to create something better than either can do alone.

It is symbiotic when each thrives because the other exists.  If newspaper editions used their print model for advertising pricing and an electronic model for website pricing perhaps there would be a creation of revenue rather than an internal battle between the website and print sales staffs to move diminishing newspaper revenues to one platform or the other.

Suppose that a newspaper website had exclusive rights to live-stream events (yes this means programming expenses) that would be covered in print and digital editions. The digital editions could have a link to the web site.

Suppose the print and digital editions used static ads and the web site used dynamic audio-visual ads (just like television).

I know that newspaper websites use audio-visual capabilities and the newspaper digital editions link to their websites. What is missing is a concerted strategy to make both the website and the newspaper editions successful. Based on what I have seen this is due to separate management teams for each platform. Advertising sales tries to bundle (which usually results in inaccurately valuing the strength of each platform) or discount ad buys based on the number of platforms being used. Content managers work on creating value for each platform, which, in turn, disallows a collaborative approach to building a synergistic, symbiotic strategy.

This outcome underscores the newspaper industry’s inability to understand that the Internet was not and is not a disruptive innovation that requires two separate organizations. The Internet is a sustaining innovation that allows industry leaders to better serve their best customers.  A sustaining innovation requires one organization focused on an overarching strategy to create value for customers, the company and any collaborators.

So here it is, if you want to save newspapers have one mission – to provide information and entertainment to as large an audience as possible. This mission should have the vision of:
1)   Using multiple media platforms to create value for audiences of all sizes,
2)   Create content that has value to audiences and advertisers,
3)   Manage content to appear on the platform that provides the best outcome,
4)   Create partnerships with entertainment and information groups to provide unique experiences for readers and advertisers.
5)   And so on.


Now setting objectives should be somewhat easier and it should be apparent that all platforms have to be engaged in strategy, tactics and execution discussions. If all platforms are not engaged in the same strategy, newspaper organizations will not be successful.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

NEW PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT PROCESS

Image
NEW PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT PROCESS As markets and customer preferences change companies adapt to insure success. Adaptations usually are made to capitalize on markets and expertise a firm has developed over its life . Some adaptations are limited to updating packaging or marketing approaches or finding new uses for established products. There are occasions where new products are needed in order to meet new customer needs or address a disruptive market innovation. When addressing changing market needs and market disruptions it is necessary to find good ideas and then have a process to evaluate and narrow the field to the ideas most likely to succeed. Generating new product ideas The first step in generating good ideas that will further develop the markets and expertise that defines the firm is to clearly articulate the job customers are hiring the firm to perform. Here it is important not to be too restrictive in the focus of the definition. It is probab...
Read more

10 Considerations for Pricing a Product or Service

When introducing a new product or service to the market a key, and often critical, consideration is the price for this offering. I have seen folks simply take the cost of production and use a percent mark up as a pricing model. This is the simplest model and it provides a good example for the need to consider other pricing model options. Here are 10 things to consider before setting a price for your product or service: ·       Mark up Based on Cost Vs Retail . In the opening paragraph I gave the example of a model being used that marked up a product by a percent over the cost. The cost used here is generally direct cost or labor and materials. If someone wants a 30% of the asking price to be the mark up, then using 30% of cost won’t provide the desired outcome. Simply put, it is the wrong math. If something costs $1 to make and it is marked up by 30% for a selling price of $1.30 then the profit of based on the asking price...
Read more

Grow Your Business Through Community Involvement and Leadership

Business is built on relationships that start with individuals and grow to include groups and institutions. Community involvement is an excellent means of creating opportunities to meet individuals and develop meaningful relationships. Whether you are a large company or a small, family-run operation relationships built through community involvement pays big dividends.   For companies considering how to get involved in the community, here are some pointers for choosing the best activities for your company. 1) Don’t choose too many activities. Stay within the bounds of your financial and human resources. The goal here is to have a successful business that grows and participates in the community. 2) Choose activities that help employees grow in the community and develop new networks. Most Chambers of Commerce have Leadership programs for developing community leaders. These programs are excellent and bring long-term benefits for the organization and the employee...
Read more